Talk:Below the Silken Chapel: The Spider-Council/@comment-203.106.159.21-20150630141818/@comment-89.133.136.10-20150630143044

I came here with the same question.

I assume, they want to continue the story, and differentiate based on your previous decision. But they did not store this information it in the past (Only Arachnologist 2), so they ask you. Probably, if someone plays this story in the future, the game will automatically  store their choice.

If you select 'Slayed it', you get Arachnologist 4.