Talk:The answer to Nightmares?/@comment-25720819-20141126120242

i just tried entering the card with nightmares 1 and using a goldfish to have nightmares be 0 for the calculations. i got lucky but still gained 2 cp to nightmares. i want to see whether the nightmare gain on success is also fixed at 2 or if the game uses the original nighmare stat (1) instead of the modified one (1-1=0).

everyone, please record some results to clear this and victis' secrets theory up.

ps: there might be a cap on appalling secrets. i have 195 and didnt gain any ('Appalling Secrets remains unchanged at 195'). OR you actually DO gain (4x nightmares) secrets and it DID calculate with nightmares 0. but then why was it mentioned?