Thread:Mikey thinkin/@comment-25219384-20180319150101/@comment-25219384-20180319230139

It's indeed a bit confusing, and some of this is from the history of the Social Action templates. You're right the some of the effects repeat themselves. The current convention on the wiki (at least for auto social actions) has been:


 * For the sender:
 * List all effects in the "Success rewards" field (the sender sees these as the direct results of their action).
 * List only the specialized text of the (right-hand side) message tab in the "Accept description" field (no need to repeat the effects already shown).
 * For the receiver:
 * List all effects (shown on the right-hand side message tab) on the "Friend Accept description"

Now, the new interactive type of social actions have the Respond option on the left-hand side message tab. It might be worth having a separate template for this, but for now, the convention (for readability's sake) has been:
 * In addition to listing all effects on the "Friend Accept description" field, also add there a Redirect to the storylet which comes from "Respond".

So, unless (or until) we decide on a new template type for these, the above is how it's done. To incorporate the Challenge Results into this existing structure, I'd indeed suggest to keep all of the above intact, and just include in the new Challenge Results section those effects which come directly from winning/losing the challenge.

There's also (some) precedent. Look here:
 * Results unique to the Sender: under "When Sent"
 * The text message seen by the sender: under "In Messages Tab" / "You will receive" (not repeating the effects)
 * Results unique to the Receiver: under "In Messages Tab" / "Your friend will receive"
 * Redirect to the next storylet when choosing Respond: under "In Messages Tab" / "Your friend will receive"
 * Results based on who has won the debate: in a separate section at the end.