Talk:Follow them to the well/@comment-86.170.178.130-20140830083238/@comment-23895476-20140901211938

There's no text there saying what the rewards are dependent on for this option, and menace isn't reduced, it is increased. For a Strange Catch 8 I just got this default success:

35 x Appalling Secret

3 x Tale of Terror!!

2 x Extraordinary Implication

250 x Cryptic Clue

Nightmares +4 CP

5 x Zee-Ztory

Total value: 19.25 Echoes

I spent 4 x Zee-Ztory and 1 x Partial Map to get to 38 CPs, so after deducting 4.50 Echoes this was only 14.75 Echoes in 11 Actions, not counting Actions spent rerolling Sights at the Festival.