Talk:Spar with a Black Ribbon Duellist/@comment-94.243.228.228-20161127105127/@comment-25219384-20170101080422

Interesting. Usually, a rare (or alternative) success will have a different success title and text. Maybe this was indeed changed, or maybe the results include a random 0-1 x Bottle of Morelways 1872 (so sometimes you get it, sometimes you don't).

Did you happen to already have any of the 1872 in your inventory? Usually, if the results are random and might provide 0 of an item, then no message is displayed if you already had none. But if you had some of the item, then the message is usually: "XXX remains unchanged, at YYY".

Needs more experimentation.