Talk:Going Fishing/@comment-1.9.102.135-20150820131831/@comment-130.63.97.124-20160819162315

More to the point, I failed a Melancholy challenge, and gained Melancholy, while not losing any quirks.

Arguably, this means that if you just want a 5 catch for menace reduction, you should fail one test per fishing trip to get a "free" quirk increase.